Every franchise eventually goes back to the beginning, and Panem has now done it twice. “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” hits theaters Nov. 20 from Lionsgate. It takes us back to the Second Quarter Quell, the 50th Hunger Games, where each district has to send four tributes instead of two. One of them is a 16-year-old from District 12 named Haymitch Abernathy. Before the bottle, the sarcasm, and the mentor’s chair, there was a boy named Haymitch Abernathy who still believed he might have a future.
Director Francis Lawrence comes back to the world he has shaped since “Catching Fire,” along with longtime producers Nina Jacobson and Brad Simpson. That experience shows. The film looks expensive and confident, and the Capitol is as gaudy and cruel as ever. When “Sunrise on the Reaping” works, it reminds you why this series became a generational touchstone. It’s about spectacle used as state control, children treated as currency, and the cost of entertainment built on suffering.
The trouble is that the film knows its audience already knows how this ends, and too often it settles for that.
Joseph Zada carries the film as young Haymitch. He had significant expectations to meet following Woody Harrelson's portrayal, yet he refrains from attempting to imitate him. He plays the raw material Harrelson’s version came from: quick wit, a defiant streak, and a growing sense that the system is rigged long before the arena proves it. In the film’s best moments you can see the bitterness forming in real time, and that’s the kind of performance work that makes a prequel worth making.
The love story is the emotional anchor, and it lands. Whitney Peak plays Lenore Dove Baird, a Covey girl from District 12 tied by blood and music to Lucy Gray Baird from “The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.” Peak gives Lenore Dove warmth and a free spirit that fits the role. Her scenes with Zada have a tenderness the rest of the film often lacks. Because we know where Haymitch ends up, every gentle moment between them carries a quiet ache, and that dramatic irony does real work.
The adult cast is stacked. Ralph Fiennes is chilling as President Snow, and Jesse Plemons brings his usual unsettling calm as a young Plutarch Heavensbee. Elle Fanning plays a younger Effie Trinket, and Kieran Culkin plays Caesar Flickerman, the Capitol’s television host. Culkin, in particular, appears to be thoroughly enjoying himself. He nails the smiling menace of a man who sells murder as must-see TV.
The pacing is the biggest problem. The film takes its time getting to the arena, and once it gets there, long stretches drag. Prequels must strike a delicate balance, as audiences are already familiar with the survivors. This awareness requires the film to create tension through alternative methods, such as character development, thematic exploration, or unexpected twists. Too often, the film simply recounts events that are predictable from the moment of the opening reaping. The story beats are predictable, and the script often oversimplifies them.
The bigger missed opportunity is the young ensemble. The film is a story about four tributes per district, and the film has talented young actors to fill those roles. McKenna Grace plays Maysilee Donner, the original owner of the mockingjay pin. Ben Wang plays Wyatt Callow, the District 12 oddsmaker from a family of gamblers. Maya Hawke plays a young Wiress. Each of them has a character the film could have built a sequence around. Instead, too many of them are sketched in and then sidelined. When the arena takes them, the loss doesn’t hit as intensely as it should, because the film never gave us enough time with them. Grace especially deserved more.
In the end, “Sunrise on the Reaping” has enough enjoyable moments to justify the trip. There’s a love story that earns its tears, a lead performance that reframes a beloved character, and a final stretch that ties neatly into the mythology fans have followed since 2012. Die-hard fans will leave happy, and they’re the audience this film was made for.
Casual viewers may wish Lawrence had taken a few more risks. The Hunger Games series excels when it disturbs us, compelling us to critically examine our desire for it. “Sunrise on the Reaping” is a well-crafted return to Panem, but it frequently opts for a cautious approach.
