‘Rose’ review: Sandra Hüller is brilliant in a year that could bring her two Oscar nominations

Sandra Hüller is brilliant in “Rose.” This performance is the one that could earn her two Oscar nominations this season.

Markus Schleinzer’s black-and-white drama, Austria’s official entry for best international feature at the 99th Academy Awards, opens in select U.S. theaters Dec. 11 from MUBI. It is set in 17th-century Germany, in the time of the Thirty Years’ War. A quiet, scarred soldier arrives in a remote Protestant village, claims an abandoned farmstead as an inheritance and backs the claim with a document. Hard work and piety win the villagers over. But the soldier is a woman, Rose, living as a man, and everything she builds there rests on that secret.

Hüller won the Silver Bear for best leading performance when the film premiered in competition at the Berlin International Film Festival in February. She is, without a doubt, one of the world’s best actresses. You can see her talent in the choices she makes in “Rose,” especially during the silent moments that reveal so much about Rose and her ongoing struggles.

That quiet is the whole assignment. Rose cannot explain herself to anyone in the village, and the film provides her no confession scene to lean on. Every day she spends on that farm, she risks being found out, so much of what she is fighting has to come through without words. That is where Hüller does her most revealing work.

Schleinzer surrounds her with a tight ensemble. Caro Braun plays Suzanna, Robert Gwisdek plays the village bailiff, and Godehard Giese plays the head farmer, the people whose trust Rose has to earn and keep. Marisa Growaldt voices the film’s narrator.

“Rose” is half of a remarkable year. Hüller also stars in Paweł Pawlikowski’s “Fatherland,” which won the best director prize at the Cannes Film Festival, shared with another film, and opened in U.S. theaters Oct. 23 from MUBI. She plays the writer and anti-Nazi campaigner Erika Mann, riding with her father, Thomas Mann, played by Hanns Zischler, across a divided Germany in the summer of 1949. Like “Rose,” it is in black and white, and it is Poland’s Oscar entry.

That gives MUBI two of the season’s international feature contenders with the same actor at the center, and the distributor has made its move. It is campaigning Hüller as lead actress for “Rose” and as supporting actress for “Fatherland,” so the two performances will not compete against each other.

The precursors are already following. Hüller is nominated twice for European actress at the European Film Awards, once for each film, alongside Penélope Cruz, Renate Reinsve, Léa Seydoux, and Mathilde Arcel. The awards will be handed out Jan. 16 in Athens. At the Gotham Awards on Nov. 30 in New York, she is up for outstanding supporting performance for “Fatherland.”

Academy voters know her. Hüller earned a best actress nomination for “Anatomy of a Fall,” and two more this season would bring her total to three.

Schleinzer spent years as a casting director for Michael Haneke and others before directing “Michael” (2011) and “Angelo” (2018). He wrote “Rose” with Alexander Brom. Gerald Kerkletz shot it, Tara Nome Doyle wrote the score, Doris Bartelt designed the costumes, and Olivier Meidinger handled production design. The film’s four European Film Award nominations are for Hüller, Doyle’s score, Bartelt’s costumes, and Meidinger’s production design.

“Rose” runs 93 minutes and is in German. It opened in Austria and Germany in April. The Oscar shortlist for international feature arrives Dec. 15, four days after it opens here.

Watch what Hüller does when no one is speaking. That is where “Rose” lives, and it is why her name belongs in the conversation twice this season.

Follow the race on Cup of Soul’s Awards Tracker.

⭐ Make Cup of Soul your go-to. Add us as a preferred source on Google, and our reviews, interviews and festival coverage will show up first when you search. Add Cup of Soul on Google →
Next
Next

‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ review: Brad Pitt’s fixer turns 1977 Hollywood into a wild ride