Zoe Kazan's Netflix limited series has career-high work from Pugh, Mike Faist, and Hoon Lee, but its seven hours don't always know what to do between the big moments.
"I believe there are monsters born to human parents." Zoe Kazan's "East of Eden" opens on Cathy Ames, not on the Salinas Valley, and that choice tells you exactly what kind of adaptation the series is. It is Cathy's show. When it stays with her, it is electric. When it doesn't, it can feel like a very handsome homework assignment.
Netflix released all seven episodes of the limited series Oct. 1. Kazan, who adapted John Steinbeck's 1952 novel and serves as co-showrunner with Jeb Stuart, carries a family history into the project. Her grandfather, Elia Kazan, directed the 1955 film that made James Dean a star. The 1955 film only adapted the final portion of Steinbeck's novel. This version takes on the whole sprawling saga, from the Trask brothers' challenging Connecticut boyhood to the next generation in California, and it reaches for the novel's biblical bones: Cain and Abel, played out again and again across three generations.
Florence Pugh is the reason to watch. Her Cathy is a survivor, a liar, and something colder than either, and Pugh refuses to let the audience settle on one reading. One moment she seems like a wounded young woman taken in by two brothers. The next, the warmth drains from her face, and you realize she has been calculating the whole time. Pugh, who also executive produced, plays one of American literature's most notorious villains without asking for sympathy or apologizing for her. It is a bold, frightening, magnetic performance, and it will be remembered at awards time.
Mike Faist matches her in the show's early stretch. As Charles Trask, the brother who never feels loved enough, Faist is all coiled jealousy and buried hurt. He gives Charles a physical restlessness, like a man who can't stand still in his skin, and his scenes opposite Christopher Abbott's Adam crackle with resentment that goes back to childhood. Charles is the first Cain of the story, and Faist makes you understand him even as you fear him. He is the actor who reads Cathy most clearly from the start, and the series is sharpest when his suspicion and her performance collide.
Abbott has the harder job as Adam, the gentle, trusting brother whose goodness becomes a kind of blindness. He plays Adam's devotion to Cathy with real ache. But Adam's grief, once it arrives, takes up long stretches of screen time, and the series does not always find the energy to carry it.
Hoon Lee is the quiet revelation. As Lee, the educated Chinese immigrant who raises Adam's sons, he brings wit, dignity, and moral weight to a character whose adaptations are sidelined. His scenes deliver some of the series' best writing, and he becomes the show's conscience. Joseph Zada, as the grown Cal, carries the final chapters with a restless hunger that echoes Faist's Charles, which is exactly the point.
The craft is lush. The series, filmed in New Zealand to represent California, boasts stunning visuals, featuring golden fields, firelit interiors, and period-appropriate costumes that enhance each scene's authenticity. The supporting bench, including Tracy Letts, Martha Plimpton, and Ciarán Hinds, is deep.
The problems are pacing and balance. The opening episodes are slow and unrelentingly grim, and seven hours turns out to be both too long and too short for this book. Some characters get rushed, while the men's long stretches of suffering are given more room than they can fill. When Cathy disappears from the center of the story, so does much of the tension.
Kazan deserves credit for ambition and for reframing Cathy as a person, not just a symbol of evil. This is a serious, intelligent adaptation that respects its source. It just doesn't always know what to do with the space between its best scenes.
"East of Eden" is worth watching for Pugh, Faist, and Lee. Come for the performances, and be patient with the rest. It is not the definitive version of Steinbeck's masterpiece, but it is a worthy one.
"East of Eden" is streaming on Netflix.
Watch Cup of Soul Show's interview with Mike Faist below.
